HomeSportFootballBishops Cleeve FC 'threaten to take matters to higher level' if promotion...

Bishops Cleeve FC ‘threaten to take matters to higher level’ if promotion is denied

By Richard Briggs

The Marcliff Gloucestershire County League promotion saga has taken another twist, with Bishops Cleeve FC “threatening to take their case to a higher level than the Gloucestershire FA” if their Development side are denied the step up.

Cleeve, champions of uhlsport Hellenic League Division Two West, are one of three teams chasing two promotion places to the Step 7 County League that has members in Gloucestershire, South Gloucestershire and Bristol.

The promotion-chasing trio – also including Gloucestershire Northern Senior League winners Tewkesbury Town and uhlsport Bristol Premier Combination League champs Winterbourne United – have been taking part in a three-way play-off competition to decide which pair will go up for the 2025-26 campaign.

The Mitres defeated Winterbourne 4-1 in the first of the play-off matches, on 10 May. And with Winterbourne beating Tewkesbury on penalties in the next fixture, anything other than a heavy loss for Cleeve against Town would elevate the Kayte Lane outfit.

However, Winterbourne protested to the Gloucestershire FA (GFA) that Cleeve had fielded an ineligible player, Ryan Baines, in the 10 May clash at county headquarters, Oaklands Park in Almondsbury.

The GFA agreed, declaring the match null and void and ordering that it must be replayed if the Mitres failed to overcome Tewkesbury on 21 May. Town triumphed 1-0 – meaning Cleeve would have to face Winterbourne again.

Cleeve pointed out that, prior to the 10 May game, they were told by David Neale, the GFA’s chief executive officer, that Baines was eligible to play against Winterbourne. Neale’s comments came in an email that has been seen by The Cheltenham Post. Neale wrote: “I’m please [sic] to confirm Ryan Baines is approved to play.”

After the tie was played, with Baines featuring on the pitch, the GFA told the Mitres that Baines was not eligible.

However, The Cheltenham Post has seen proof that Baines played more than five games this season for Cleeve’s under-18s – a lower team than the club’s Development squad – so making him eligible to play in this month’s play-offs.

A source close to Bishops Cleeve FC told The Cheltenham Post this evening (Tuesday 27 May): “Ryan Baines was at all times eligible to play against Winterbourne in the play-offs.

“Permission/dispensation was not actually required. Winterbourne were beaten fair and square by a team fielding eligible players. The match [against Winterbourne] does not need to be replayed.”

The source added that Cleeve are considering taking matters to a higher level than the GFA to ensure their Development team are promoted.

In a statement released at 7.22pm today, the Mitres said: “Bishops Cleeve Football Club would like to reaffirm our position on the unsatisfactory course of events relating to our Development team’s participation in the Gloucestershire County League play-off competition.

“BCFC beat Winterbourne United 4-1 on Saturday 10 May, before losing 1-0 to Tewkesbury Town on Wednesday 21 May.

“The player in question deemed ineligible against Winterbourne United is a registered BCFC player, under the GFA registration process, and had played more than five games for BCFC in the under-18 team, ie even lower than the club’s reserve/Development team.

“He therefore came full square within eligibility Rule 2 of the competition and was therefore eligible to compete in the Gloucestershire County League play-offs.

“The rule is there to prevent teams importing players for the play-offs at the last minute from other clubs, particularly playing at a higher level. This did not happen here.

“Today BCFC heard that the panel decided the player was ineligible because the GFA failed to follow its own procedure when granting permission.

“However, it is also clear from the decision that dispensation was not actually required by BCFC in any event as the player was eligible to play under the rules.

“BCFC is now taking advice on how to overturn the panel error and calls upon all involved, including Winterbourne United, to do the right thing.

“BCFC will not be taking part in an unnecessary replay of its match with Winterbourne United.

“BCFC have complied with the rules of the competition, and in accordance with the rules our Development team have qualified for promotion to the Gloucestershire County League without any further matches to be played.

“BCFC look forward to our Devs competing in the upcoming 2025-26 Gloucestershire
County League season.”

The Cheltenham Post did not discover until shortly before 5pm today that Baines had played the correct number of games for Cleeve under-18s to ensure he was eligible for the play-offs.

The Cheltenham Post went by the book by contacting the GFA, at 5.13pm, on their published email address for press queries. Our email asked:

  • Why did Neale tell Cleeve that Baines was clear to play against Winterbourne, only for the GFA to tell Cleeve after that match that Baines was ineligible?
  • Why were Cleeve told Baines is ineligible when he has played enough qualifying games to make him eligible?
  • Will the Cleeve v Winterbourne match be replayed or will the 10 May result stand and are Cleeve promoted?

    We stated, in the email marked as urgent, that as this is a breaking story and it would be appearing on our website this evening, a reply would be needed by 8pm today.

    An automatic reply was received, stating that the GFA office closed at 5pm and would reopen at 9am on Wednesday 28 May.

    So going beyond what is required of a media outlet chasing a comment from an organisation, The Cheltenham Post then contacted three members of GFA staff – including Neale and fellow high-ranker Chris Lucker, the head of football services – on their individual GFA email addresses asking the same questions.

    The Cheltenham Post received no response by the 8pm deadline.

    It must be pointed out that The Cheltenham Post contacted the GFA by email on Tuesday 20 May with other questions relating to the Baines situation; this was also a breaking story. This email was also marked as urgent, and the GFA were given more than five hours to reply. The GFA failed to respond to those questions by the deadline on 20 May, or indeed at any time since.

If you have a story for the Post’s website email him at digitaleditor@cheltenhampost.co.uk

If you would like to advertise on the Post’s website, call Commercial Director Mark Cuzner on 07983 179225 or email him at mark@cheltenhampost.co.uk.

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments